|
EMPLOYMENT-BASED
IMMIGRATION
I. Scope of
Article
II. First
Preference: Priority Workers
III. Second
Preference: Workers who are members of the professions holding advanced degrees
or of except ability in the sciences , arts or business
IV. Third
Preference: Skilled workers, professionals and other workers
V. Other Issues
VI. Conclusion
I. SCOPE OF ARTICLE
The Immigration and Nationality Act of 1952 (hereinafter INA)
provides for several employment-based immigrant visa classifications, all of
which have built-in protections for the U .S. labor market. Indeed,
employment-based immigration generally requires either a strong showing that the
foreign worker is one of the best in the field or that there are no qualified U
.S. workers available to fill the position.
This article addresses the first three categories of employment-based
immigration and details the statutory and regulatory requirements for each
classification. The employment-based immigration categories are commonly
referred to as EB-1, EB-2, and EB-3, as follows: First Preference (EB-1
priority workers); Second Preference (EB-2 workers with advanced degrees or
exceptional ability); and Third Preference (EB-3 professionals, skilled workers,
and other workers).
The law allocates 120,000 visas per year in these categories in
total. Until recently, the EB-1 and EB-2 categories rarely reached the statutory
cap. And, with certain exceptions, the EB-3 category generally remains
available. However, for natives of lndia and China, the EB-2 and EB-3 categories
are seriously oversubscribed at present, and even the EB-1 category is
oversubscribed for individuals from China. Consequently, it has become more
challenging to maintain these individuals' nonimmigrant visa status while
pursuing employment-based immigrant visa status until they can make the final
application for permanent residence.
[ Go back
to top of page ]
II. FIRST PREFERENCE: PRIORITY WORKERS
A. Statutory: Categories
INA § 203(b)(1)2 allocates 28.6 percent of the total number of
employment-based immigrant visas per year to priority workers in three
subcategories, which together comprise the EB-1 classification:
I. Workers of extraordinary ability; 2. Outstanding professors
and researchers; and 3. Multinational executives and managers. There is
no allocation of the available visas among the subcategories of priority
workers.
When evaluating whether a worker qualifies for any first preference
category, the practitioner should also consider: I. The EB-2 category
-Exceptional ability in the sciences, arts or business under INA § 203(b)(2),
8 USC § 1153(b)(2); and 2. Workers of exceptional ability in the sciences
or arts under Schedule A, Group II, codified at INA § 212(a)(5)(A)(ii)(II),
8USC § 1182(a)(5)(A). These alternatives are discussed briefly in this
article and in more detail elsewhere in this
Volume.
B. Regulations The regulations for priority
workers enumerate the criteria for each of the three categories. The first
category, workers of extraordinary ability; the second category, outstanding
professors and researchers; and the third category , multinational managers and
executives are each discussed in more detail below.
C. Aliens of Extraordinary
Ability Workers of extraordinary ability are defined by statute as
those who can show that they have "extraordinary ability in the sciences, arts,
education, business or athletics which has been demonstrated by sustained
national or international acclaim and whose achievements have been recognized in
the field through extensive documentation."11 The regulations follow legislative
history by defining extraordinary ability as a level of expertise indicating
that the individual is one of "that small percentage who have risen to the very
top of the field of endeavor." In other words, the worker should be the cream of
the crop. I. Basic Requirements
a. No Job Offer or Labor Certification Required
(1) One of the main advantages of classifying an individual as an EB-l
worker of extraordinary ability is that neither a job offer nor a labor
certification is required. Although an employer can petition for an EB-l
worker of extraordinary ability , the foreign national can petition for
himself or herself (self-petition) without an employer. (2) Whether the
petitioner is an employer or the foreign national, the petition must include
evidence that the individual will continue to work in the United States in the
area of expertise. Such evidence includes:
(a) Letters from prospective
employers: (b) Evidence of prearranged commitments for employment;
or (c) A description of how he or she will continue to work in the field in
the United States. b. Criteria for Qualifying for EB-I Extraordinary
Ability Status Receipt of a major, internationally recognized award, on its
own, can qualify an individual for EB-I classification. An example of such an
award is the Nobel Prize. Other awards, not as notable, might also qualify,
but the practitioner will have to document that the particular award rises to
the level of a Nobel Prize or awards of a similar nature. Most foreign
nationals will not be Nobel Prize recipients. Fortunately, the regulations
provide for alternative evidence if the worker has not received a single
internationally-recognized award. To satisfy the alternative requirement, the
petition must include evidence that the individual satisfies at least three of
the following criteria: (I) receipt of lesser nationally or internationally
recognized prizes or awards for excellence; (2) membership in associations
in the field that demand outstanding achievement of their members; (3)
published material about the alien; (4) evidence that the alien is a judge
of the work of others in the field; (5) evidence of the alien's original
contributions of major significance to the field; (6) authorship of
scholarly articles; (7) display of the alien's work at artistic exhibitions
or showcases; (8) evidence the alien has performed in a leading or critical
role for organizations that have a distinguished reputation; (9) evidence
that the alien commands high remuneration in relation to others in the field;
or (10) evidence of commercial success in the performing arts. If the
above criteria do not apply, the regulations also allow for "other comparable
evidence."
In practice, the EB-1 extraordinary ability category seems easier to
satisfy than Schedule A, Group II. First, the EB-1 category completely sidesteps
the job offer and the need for an employer petitioner. Schedule A, Group II,
however, requires an employer and a firm job offer. Second, EB- 1 extraordinary
ability may be established by satisfying three of ten criteria. The
extraordinary ability criteria also recognize national or international acclaim
or achievement. Schedule A, Group II, on the other hand, emphasizes
international acclaim and requires that the petitioner satisfy two of only seven
criteria. In addition, Schedule A, Group II classification requires separate and
independent evidence of exceptional ability through documentation of current
widespread acclaim and international recognition by other experts. The
practitioner should consider both classifications, however, because both remain
available. In its final permanent labor certification rule, the Department of
Labor retained Schedule A, Group II because it was persuaded that some foreign
nationals who qualify in this group might not qualify for priority worker status
as individuals of extraordinary ability .
The statute also requires a showing that the EB-1 extraordinary
ability worker will "substantially benefit prospectively the United States."
However, INS has opined that, as a general rule, satisfying at least three of
the stringent regulatory criteria constitutes evidence that the worker will
benefit the United States. In addition, an opinion issued by the INS General
Counsel imposes limitations on the scope of the extraordinary ability category
.According to the opinion, "professionals" do not qualify for EB-1 extraordinary
ability status unless the profession in which they are engaged can be
categorized as in the arts, sciences, business, education, or
athletics.
2. Procedures INS Form 1-140, Petition for Alien Worker, is
required. It may be filed by the foreign national as a self-petitioner or by an
employer. In either case, like all other I -140 petitions, the EB-1 petition
must be filed at the INS Service Center that has jurisdiction over the place
where the individual will work.23 The petition packet must include the 1-140 and
the required documentary evidence. Each Service Center publishes specific filing
guidelines. The practitioner should obtain and carefully follow those
guidelines.
D. Outstanding Professors and
Researchers The second subcategory of priority workers is outstanding
professors and researchers. These workers are professors and researchers who are
internationally recognized for their outstanding achievements.
I. Basic Requirements To qualify as an outstanding professor or
researcher, the foreign national must:
a. be internationally recognized as outstanding in a specific
academic field; b. have a minimum of three years of experience in teaching
and/or research in that field; and c. enter the U.S. in a tenure or
tenure-track teaching or comparable research position at a university or other
institution of higher education, or in a comparable research position with a
private employer under certain circumstances
Research positions must be "permanent." A "permanent" position is defined
at 8 CFR § 204.5(i)(2) as "tenured, tenure-track, or for a term of indefinite or
unlimited duration" with the expectation of continued employment, unless there
is good cause for termination. Thus, an offer of employment that is of
indefinite duration, but terminable at will, likely satisfies the requirement of
"permanent" employment.
The employer need not be a university or educational institution. The
employer can be a private company, but it must employ at least three full-time
researchers. The private employer also must have documented accomplishments in
the academic field for which the position is offered. Although one would
normally expect outstanding researchers and professors to have Ph.D. degrees,
neither the statute nor regulations requires possession of a doctorate.
Furthermore, a foreign national who qualifies as an outstanding professor can be
offered a position as a researcher, and vice versa.
2. Three Years Experience The outstanding professor or researcher must
have at least three years of experience. However, the requisite three years can
include pre-degree research experience gained while working on the advanced
degree, so long as the foreign national completed the degree and the pre-degree
research experience is recognized as outstanding. In addition, pre-degree
teaching experience is acceptable if the individual had full responsibility for
the course. Nothing in the statute or regulations precludes reliance on
experience gained with the petitioning employer. Additionally, any combination
of teaching or research totaling three years will serve to meet the experience
requirement.
3. Standards The outstanding professor or researcher must satisfy at
least two of the following criteria:
a. receipt of major prizes or awards; b. membership in
associations that require outstanding achievements; c. published material
in professional journals written by others about the alien's work; d.
participation as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied
field; e. original scientific or scholarly research contributions to the
field; or f. authorship of scholarly books or articles in scholarly
journals with international circulation in the
field.
4. Procedures INS Form I -140, Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker,
must be filed with the INS Service Center having jurisdiction over the place of
employment. However, unlike the EB-1 worker of extraordinary ability ,the
outstanding professor or researcher cannot petition for himself or herself. The
employer must file the petition.
E. Certain Multinational Executives and
Managers The third subcategory of the EB-1 classification is reserved
for executives and managers of foreign companies who are transferred to the
United States.
1. Basic Requirements The requirements for this classification
closely track those for L-1A intracompany transferees. A multinational manager
or executive is eligible for priority worker status if he or she has been
employed outside the U .S. in a managerial or executive capacity for at least
one of the three years immediately preceding the filing of the petition, or, in
the case of a foreign worker presently in the U.S., one of the three years
preceding entry to the U.S. as a nonimmigrant. The regulations (but not the
statute) require the past employment to have been outside the U.S. and in a
managerial or executive capacity. The past employment must have been with the
same employer, an affiliate, or a subsidiary of the employer. The foreign worker
must be coming to work in an executive or managerial capacity .
2. The Necessary Multinational Relationship The petitioner must be
a U .S. employer that is an affiliate, a subsidiary, or the same employer as the
firm, corporation or other legal entity that employed the foreign national
abroad. The U.S. petitioner must have been doing business for at least one
year.
The definitions of affiliate and subsidiary in the regulations are
comparable to those found in the L-l intracompany transferee regulations. An
"affiliate" is defined as one of two subsidiaries that are owned or controlled
by the same parent or individual or by a group of individuals, so long as each
individual owns and controls approximately the same share or percentage of each
entity. The term "affiliate" also includes certain international accounting
firms that market accounting services under an internationally recognized name.
Subsidiaries include direct or indirect ownership of at least half of another
entity , ownership of 50 percent of a 50- 50 joint venture with equal control
and veto power, or ownership of less than 50 percent of an entity with de facto
control.
3. Managerial or Executive Capacity The beneficiary must be coming to
the United States to work in a managerial or executive capacity .The definitions
of "manager" and "executive" are critical in formulating a case.
a. "Managerial capacity" is an assignment in which the employee
primarily: (1) manages the organization or a department, subdivision,
function or component of the organization; (2) supervises and controls the
work of other supervisory , professional or managerial employees or manages an
essential function within the organization, or a department or subdivision of
the organization; (3) if another employee or other employees are directly
supervised, has the authority to hire and fire or recommend those as well as
other personnel actions (such as promotion and leave authorization) or, if no
other employee is directly supervised, functions at a senior level within the
organizational hierarchy or with respect to the function managed; and (4)
exercises discretion over the day-to-day operations of the activity or
function for which the employee has authority . Note that a managerial
position does not necessarily require management of staff. Management of a
function can be sufficient, but it is generally more difficult to make the
case for a functional manager . b. "Executive capacity" means an assignment
within an organization in which the employee primarily: (1) directs the
management of the organization or a major component or function of the
organization; (2) establishes the goals and policies of the organization,
component, or function; (3) exercises wide latitude in discretionary
decision making; and (4) receives only general supervision or direction
from high- level executives, the board of directors, or stockholders of the
organization. c. INS Form 1-140, Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker, is
filed with the INS service center having jurisdiction over the place of
employment. The petition must be filed by the employer .
[ Go
back to top of page ]
III. SECOND
PREFERENCE: WORKERS WHO ARE MEMBERS OF THE PROFESSIONS HOLDING ADVANCED DEGREES
OR OF EXCEPT ABILITY IN THE SCIENCES. ARTS OR BUSINESS
A. Statutory Categories By statute,
28.6 percent (approximately 40,000) of the total number of employment- based
immigrant visas per year are allocated to second preference workers. There are
two subcategories of the second preference, which together comprise the EB-2
classification:
I. Workers who are "members of the professions holding advanced
degrees or their equivalent," and 2. Workers "who because of their
exceptional ability in the sciences, arts, or business will substantially
benefit prospectively the national economy, cultural or educational interests,
or welfare of the United States." The INS General Counsel issued an opinion
in January 1995 stating that the EB-2 classification includes athletics. There
is no allocation of the available visas according to subcategory
.
B. Regulations The regulations for
second preference workers are found at 8 CFR § 204.5(k).
C. Basic Requirements I. Members of the
Professions Holding Advanced Degrees
Any U .S. employer can file a petition in this category when the job
requires an advanced degree and the alien possesses such a degree. An advanced
degree is defined as any degree beyond the baccalaureate. Professions include,
but are not limited to, the occupations listed in INA § 101 (a)(32), as well as
any occupation for which a U .S. baccalaureate degree or foreign degree
equivalent is the minimum requirement for entry into the occupation.
The regulations do not specify that the degree must be at least a
master's degree, and some foreign degrees are evaluated as beyond a bachelor's
but short of a master's degree in the United States. However, since the position
must require an advanced degree, and there is no commonly recognized U.S. degree
between a bachelor's and a master's, it is likely that the threshold educational
requirement will, as a practical matter, be a master's degree.
As an alternative to the master's degree requirement, a baccalaureate
degree plus five years of progressive experience can serve as the equivalent of
a master's degree. However, experience may not substitute for a bachelor's
degree.
2. Workers of Exceptional Ability The use of the word "exceptional" in
various contexts in the immigration law has caused confusion. For the purpose of
showing eligibility for EB-2 classification as a worker of exceptional ability
in the sciences, arts (including athletics) or business, the individual must
have a degree of expertise significantly above the ordinary , This is
established by satisfying at least three of the following six
criteria:
a. An official academic record showing a degree, diploma,
certificate or similar award from a college, university , school or other
institution of learning relating to the area of exceptional ability; b, At
least ten years of full-time experience in the occupation documented by
letters from current or past employers; c. A license to practice the
profession or certification for the particular profession or occupation; d.
Evidence that the alien has commanded a salary or other remuneration for
services demonstrating exceptional ability; e. Membership in professional
associations (there is no requirement that the professional associations
require outstanding achievement for admission); or f. Recognition for
achievements and significant contributions to the industry or field by peers,
governmental entities or professional or business organizations. Other
comparable evidence is also acceptable. These standards are clearly
distinguishable from, and easier to satisfy than, the standards for
pre-certification under Schedule A, Group II (discussed
below),
3. Procedures The petitioner must file INS Form 1-140, Petition for
Alien Worker, for an E8-2 worker at the INS Service Center having jurisdiction
over the place of employment. As a general rule, the petition must include an
individual labor certification from the DOL, with evidence that the individual
meets the requirements for the job set forth in the labor certification.
Alternatively, for Schedule A, Group I (physical therapists and nurses) or Group
II (aliens of exceptional ability) designation, the petition must include a
fully executed, uncertified Form ETA 750, in duplicate, with supporting
evidence.
There are, however, two exceptions to the labor certification
requirement. If the foreign national will serve the "national interest," labor
certification may be waived. To apply for the exemption, the petitioner must
submit the 1-140, along with a Form ETA 7508, Statement of Qualifications of
Alien, in duplicate, and evidence to support the claim that such exemption would
be in the national interest The "national interest" waiver is discussed
below.
The second exception to the labor certification requirement is for
worker: under Schedule A found at 20 CFR § 656.22. There is no specific
preference category for Schedule A, Group II (aliens of exceptional ability),
and no specific ho: to check on the 1-140 petition. Clearly, one may check the
box for alien o exceptional ability , or the box for skilled worker. In either
case, one should clarify in parentheses that the case is being filed under
Schedule A, Group II.
D. Labor Certification or Schedule A Aoolication
. As a general rule, E8-2 petitions must be accompanied by an approved
individual labor certification. Exceptions to the labor certification
requirement (referred to 2 "pre-certification") are available for positions
under Schedule A, Group I (for physic; therapists and nurses with advanced
degrees i/those positions require advanced degrees) an Group II (aliens of
exceptional ability in the sciences or arts). To qualify for Schedule A,
Group II, an individual must submit: 1) evidence testifying to his or her
current widespread acclaim and international recognition; 2) documentation
showing that his or her work during the past year required, and his or her
intended work will require, exceptional ability; and 3) evidence from at least
two of the following seven categories:
I. Receipt of international prizes or awards for excellence in the
field; 2. Membership in international organizations that require
outstanding achievement of their members; 3. Published material about the
alien relating to the alien' s work in professional publications; 4.
Evidence of the alien' s participation as a judge of the work of others in the
same or an allied field; 5. Original scientific or scholarly research
contributions of major significance in the field; 6. Authorship of
scientific or scholarly articles in the field in professional journals with
international circulation; or 7. Display of the alien's work at artistic
exhibitions in more than one country.
E. National Interest Exemption from Job Offer and
Labor Certification EB-2 petitioners can seek an exemption from the
requirement of a job offer- and thus labor certification -by demonstrating that
admission of the beneficiary is in the national interest. The "national
interest" test is not defined in the statute or regulations but requires a
showing "significantly above that for prospective national benefit."
Unfortunately, the statute and the regulations also fail to define "prospective
national benefit." However, the exemption "in the national interest" was
addressed in a non-precedent decision of the Administrative Appeals Office
(hereinafter AAO), popularly referred to as Matter of Mississippi Phosphate.
This case listed seven factors to consider in applying the national interest
test:
I. Improving the U.S. economy; 2. Improving wages and working
conditions of U.S. workers; 3. Improving education and training programs
for U.S. children and underqualified workers; 4. Improving health
care; 5. Providing more affordable housing for young and/or older, poorer
U.S. residents; 6. Improving the U .S. environment and making more
productive use of natural resources; or 7. A request from an interested
U.S. government agency.
This list is by no means exhaustive. The national interest waiver has
applied to a variety of fields and positions. To obtain a national interest
waiver, the petitioner must file a Form 1-140, with a Form ETA 750B (in
duplicate), at the INS Service Center having jurisdiction over the place where
the foreign national will work. The petition must include evidence that the
individual satisfies the advanced degree or exceptional ability requirements,
works in a field that is of national interest, and has the ability to impact our
national interest in that field.
It is important to note that for a national interest waiver, the
foreign national can petition without an employer. In the alternative, the
employer can petition on behalf of the foreign national, but an employer
petitioner is not required.
Note that a 1994 AAO decision states that in the case of a national
interest waiver for a worker with an advanced degree, the position need not
require an advanced degree. The only requirement is that the alien hold the
advanced degree.
In a recent precedent decision, In re New York State Dep't of
Transportation (hereinafter NYSDOT), the INS established a new three-part test
for determining national interest waiver eligibility:
I. The beneficiary must be seeking to work in an area of
"substantial intrinsic merit" " , 2. The beneficiary's prospective
employment must have a benefit that "will be national in scope;" and 3. The
beneficiary will "serve the national interest to a substantially greater
degree than would an available U .S. worker having the same minimum
qualifications." The AAO's decision clearly raises the standard for
adjudication of national interest waiver petitions.
[ Go back
to top of page ]
IV. THIRD PREFERENCE: SKILLED WORKERS,
PROFESSIONALS AND OTHER WORKERS
A. Statutory Definition By statute,
28.6 percent of the total number of employment-based immigrant visas per year
are allocated to third preference workers in three
subcategories:
I. Skilled workers (at least two years of experience required) 2.
Professionals (baccalaureate degree required for position and alien) 3.
Other workers (less than two years experience required for
position).
For purposes of determining availability of visas, there is no allocation
between professionals and skilled workers. Visas are currently available in most
employment- sponsored categories, but from time to time certain countries
experience a backlog, as is currently the case with India and China.
A substantial backlog exists, though, for visas in the "other
workers" category Thus, the distinction between "professionals" and "skilled
workers," on the one hand, and "other workers," on the other, plays an extremely
important role. As a practical matter, the practitioner should seriously
consider other visa alternatives before seeking classification as an EB-3 "other
worker."
B. Regulations The regulations for EB-3
workers are found at 8 CFR § 204.5(1).
C. Skilled Workers
Skilled workers are those in positions that require a minimum of two
years of training or experience. Relevant post-secondary education counts as
training. The requirements of the job offer as stated on the Form ET A- 750A
labor certification application determine whether a job is skilled or unskilled.
In drafting labor certifications, the employer should determine whether the job
matches a position in the Dictionary of Occupational Titles with a Specific
Vocational Preparation code of at least six (one to two years experience
required) so the position will be classified as a skilled one. If the position
is pre-certified under Schedule A, the petitioner must show, by either industry
standards or its own past practice, that the job requires two years of
experience.
D. Professionals Professionals must
possess a baccalaureate degree or foreign degree equivalent, and the petitioner
must demonstrate that such a degree is the normal requirement for entry into the
occupation. There is no provision for equivalency based upon a combination of
education and experience. Thus, if the ETA 750A form specifies "Bachelor's or
equivalent," a foreign national will not qualify for EB-3 classification as a
professional if he or she lacks a bachelor's or foreign equivalent degree.
However, any foreign national who would claim such equivalency is likely to have
at least two years of training or experience and thus qualify as a skilled
worker.
E. Other Workers Other workers include
those unlucky enough to be in positions requiring less than two years of higher
education, training, or experience. The current backlog for this category is
lengthy, approximately ten years, but because advancement fluctuates, the wait
could be even longer. Whether the backlog increases or decreases, though, it is
still a matter of several years of waiting to obtain a visa in this category ,
unless Congress allocates more visa numbers. If an employer has already obtained
labor certification for an employee in a position requiring less than two years
of experience, the practitioner should determine if another labor certification
could be filed for a new position requiring two years of training or
experience.
F. Procedures INS Form 1-140, Petition for
Alien Worker, must be filed with the INS Service Center having jurisdiction over
the place of employment. A labor certification or Schedule A application, as
well as a permanent, full-time job offer, is required for all 1-140 petitions
requesting EB-3 classification. There are no exceptions. The petition should
also include evidence that the individual meets the requirements for the job set
forth in the labor certification.
[ Go back
to top of page ]
V. OTHER ISSUES
A. Filing Petitions in More Than One
Category
In the past, most categories in the employment-based system, except
"other workers," have remained current. However, as of May 1999, a backlog
exists for China in the first, second and third preferences and for India in the
second and third preferences.
There have been times in the past when visas have been available for
natives of India, for example, under the third preference, but not under the
second preference. In such an instance, a third preference visa petition can be
submitted for "second preference" Indians to take advantage of the fact that
visas are currently available under the third preference, a category for which
they also qualify .
Sometimes, a client might wish to file two petitions, for example, as an
EB-1 worker of extraordinary ability , and as an EB-2 worker who will serve the
national interest. This is also acceptable and allows the client a better chance
of approval and more rapid visa availability .
When a second petition requiring a labor certification is subsequently
filed, the attorney should file the I -140 petition with proper fee and
supporting documents, including an attorney-certified photocopy of the labor
certification and, if applicable, an explanation that the original labor
certification was included with a previously filed I -140 Petition. The INS
should be provided with the prior petition's file number .
B. Priority Date If an individual labor
certification is required, the priority date is the date the request for labor
certification is accepted for processing at the local office of the employment
service agency. Otherwise, the priority date is the date the petition is
properly filed with the INS.
C. Ability to Pay Wage Any petition
filed by a U.S. employer must include evidence that the employer has been able
to pay the wage as of the alien's priority date. This evidence may consist of
the employer's annual report, federal income tax return, or audited financial
statements. If the petitioner has more than 100 employees, a statement from the
organization's financial officer will suffice.
This requirement can cause difficulty in startup companies that show
substantial growth between the time of filing and the completion of the process.
The regulations permit some flexibility because they allow petitioners to submit
additional evidence such as profit/loss statements, bank account records, or
personnel records. The petitioner should be prepared to submit evidence of
ability to pay the salary as of the date the labor certification was filed as
well as the date of filing Form 1-140.
Significantly, the AA O has broadened its view of the "ability to pay" by
holding that as long as the employer is actually paying the proffered wage when
the priority date is established, the case should not be denied for lack of
financial ability to pay the proffered wage. Thus, where the foreign worker has
been employed by the employer, copies of payroll checks, W-2 forms, and/or the
beneficiary's tax returns substantiating that the foreign worker has actually
been paid the proffered wage, should evidence the employer's ability to pay such
wage. Beware: If the foreign worker has been employed without authorization,
this might expose the employer to an I -9 employment eligibility
investigation.
[ Go back
to top of page ]
VI. CONCLUSION
The first three preferences provide a wide range of employment-based
immigration alternatives. To qualify for one of these classifications, a foreign
national must be one of the very best in his or her field, a high-ranking worker
of a multinational company, or a worker who can make a contribution in the
national interest. If that is not the case, the employer must demonstrate there
are no qualified U.S. workers available and, therefore, the services of the
foreign worker are necessary.
Thus, foreign nationals who qualify for EB-l, EB-2, or EB-3
classification are not taking something away from Americans. They are using
their special skills and brain power to contribute to the U.S. economy.
[ Go back
to top of page ]
|